Nearly two dozen Terrace Avenue residents were displaced as a result.
At least two people were rescued from the homes, before flames spread to a car parked in front of one of them, NBC reports.
Footage captured by neighbor Sky Aviles shows the moment a car tire exploded in the massive blaze that brought more than 100 firefighters to the scene.
The cause remains under investigation.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Lyndhurst and receive free news updates.